Question:
Why don't ducks echo?
LadyDJ
2008-02-12 07:50:57 UTC
My sister has told me that its a well known fact that quacks do not echo... how can this be?
Sixteen answers:
anonymous
2008-02-12 07:54:25 UTC
lol - me and my brother just watched brainiac and they tried that by putting a duck in an echoey place - when the duck quacked ... it DID echo



so i think that the fact of ducks quack not echoing is just a load of bull poo =]



x
Quizard
2008-02-12 08:14:33 UTC
I'm afraid it's an urban myth albeit a very common one.



"A duck's quack doesn't echo" is a much quoted scientific myth. In spring 2003 it was quoted on Home Truths on BBC Radio 4 and Shooting Stars on BBC 2. You can listen to our sound files on Home Truths by going to the BBC4 web site and "listening again". Salford Acoustics was the source of the story being presented in the national and international media when we proved that a duck's quack does echo as part of the British Association Festival of Science.



The myth

So a duck's quack certainly echoes around our reverberation chamber, so a duck's quack does echo. Which leads to the most interesting question, why did the myth arise? The are a few possible explanations that I can think of:



The quack does echo, but it is usually too quiet to hear. When you want to hear an echo, you usually make a very loud noise to make sure the reflection can be heard. But a duck quacks too quietly, so the reflection is too quiet to hear.

Ducks don't quack near reflecting surfaces. You need a large reflecting surface, a mountain or building for the sound to reflect off. Maybe ducks don't hang around reflecting surfaces.

It is hard to hear the echo of a sound which fades in and fades out.



It has been widely quoted in incorrect lists of facts that a duck's quack does not echo. This statement is incorrect as a duck's quack does in-fact echo.





Wikipedia defines an echo as:



A reflection of sound, arriving at the listener some time after the direct sound. Typical examples are the echo produced by the bottom of a well, by a building, or in a room, by the walls. A true echo is a single reflection of the sound source. The time delay is the extra distance divided by the speed of sound.



In tests done in an echo chamber, it was proved that a ducks quack does echo. It only takes someone to be around a cliff populated with ducks to find this out. Which leads to the most interesting question, why did the myth arise? The are a few possible explanations that could explain it are:



The quack does echo, but it is usually too quiet to hear. When you want to hear an echo, you usually make a very loud noise to make sure the reflection can be heard. But a duck quacks too quietly, so the reflection is too quiet to hear.

Ducks don't quack near reflecting surfaces. You need a large reflecting surface, a mountain or building for the sound to reflect off. Maybe ducks don't hang around reflecting surfaces.

It is hard to hear the echo of a sound which fades in and fades out.
anonymous
2008-02-12 07:55:35 UTC
A ducks quack doesn't echo very well but it does echo.
anonymous
2008-02-12 08:00:20 UTC
Shes winding you up, we have ducks and they do echo, especially very well at night when you are trying to sleep, or early morning.



for the record geese echo too.!
?
2008-02-12 07:54:48 UTC
it can't be

i have pet ducks and their quacks echo

so she i wrong
anonymous
2008-02-12 07:56:36 UTC
Urban Myth.. A wolves howl doesn't though
Monstera Deliciosa
2008-02-12 08:17:44 UTC
Nanny W has been at the cooking sherry again I see.
stamponants
2008-02-12 07:54:59 UTC
it can not be... every sound echos... even the ones we cant hear... its just WE cant hear them but they still act in the same way...
Nanny W
2008-02-12 07:59:42 UTC
I Say, what kind of STUPID question is that. I hope you know that you've just wasted 30 minutes of your life doing that question. Yes, as my old mama-nicknack used to say, dont be so bluddy stupid!! Ahh, she was such a wise woman my old mama-nicknack. HOW DARE YOU!!!!!!! You've made me cry now. Why, shame on you, hurting an old-woman like me in such a way.
feee
2008-02-12 08:35:12 UTC
after all this info now you the truth and that your sister knows little or is gullible=]
UKgirl
2008-02-12 07:59:11 UTC
lol, might be because they live on the outside...lakes... They don't live in enclosed places, e.g. a room.
zampa_cotj
2008-02-12 07:56:34 UTC
http://www.snopes.com/critters/wild/duckecho.asp



http://www.straightdope.com/classics/a5_071.html



http://www.acoustics.salford.ac.uk/acoustics_info/duck/



bottom line - it echos :)
Dave
2008-02-12 07:58:14 UTC
is this a blonde moment
dave
2008-02-12 07:56:57 UTC
they do but it is very quiet
anonymous
2008-02-12 07:53:21 UTC
It's been proven that they do
anonymous
2008-02-12 07:53:12 UTC
SHE'S PULLING YOUR LEG


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...